Leicester households facing multiple wheelie bin fines
Multiple fines are being handed out to households which fail to put their wheelie bins away after rubbish collection day.
Wardens from Leicester City Council have adopted the tactic of fining every adult living in a property £110 if they cannot establish who was responsible for not putting the bin away.
In one case, four students in a shared house were each hit with £110 penalties after failing to respond to repeated warnings.
The city council said multiple fining would help keep the streets clear of bins – avoiding clutter and potential arson.
Critics said it led to punishments out of proportion with the offence.
The council has issued 60 fixed penalties since it began its wheelie bin blitz in April. On 11 occasions, there have been multiple fines to single properties.
Former De Montfort University student Zoe Kozlik, 21, and her three housemates were each fined for leaving their bin outside their house in Windermere Street, West End.
Her father, Chris, queried the four-way fine which he thought was an administrative error.
He said: "I couldn't believe there would be four fines for one offence at one household.
"I'm not taking issue with the offence and I believe Zoe must learn to take responsibility for her actions but it doesn't seem fair to make all four girls pay £110 when they could split a single fine for a single house."
He said city council correspondence had gone unnoticed because it was posted through a letter box into a locked and unoccupied room.
He said: "They were among the first to get fines in April.
"She's an unemployed fashion graduate without a lot of money so it's me who has to pay up.
"This policy is likely to hit a lot of students who share houses."
Owen Jones, campaign and involvement officer at the University of Leicester Students' Union, said multiple fining was unfair.
He said: "It's like fining a speeding driver and all the passengers in his car at the same time.
"It is likely to affect students more than anyone else. They share houses and are away for long periods during holidays where they might not get the warnings.
"It looks like the city council is looking at students as a cash cow.
"One bin left outside a house is one bin, not four, so it isn't fair to issue four fines."
A city council spokesman said four was the largest number of people to have got a fine at one property and most of the multiple fines had gone to homes with two adults.
He said: "Fines are only issued where householders have ignored all other attempts by us to resolve the issue.
"Our city wardens give letters and information to householders and follow them up with letters or visits, to give advice and explain the need to take in bins between collections.
"If the problem persists, we will try to establish whether there are particular problems preventing people from bringing in their bins.
"If they still fail to remove their bins, legal notices are sent out.
"Each adult occupier of a house has the same amount of legal responsibility."
A spokeswoman for the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs said: "Issuing fixed-penalty notices is a matter entirely for local authorities. We do say councils must be fair and reasonable."







25 Comments
View all
by Sam, Leicester
Monday, September 07 2009, 1:23PM
“Not everyone is as stereotypical as you, Maria. Students get a bad reputation. I was a student at DMU for 3 years and not once did I set fire to a bin!!!!!!!”
by Maria, Leicester
Friday, September 04 2009, 1:11PM
“Students do NOT pay council tax. They are exempt in most cases. It also appears that the problems with bins being left out on narrow streets where they get knocked over, set alight, etc. are in areas mostly populated by, guess what? Students! Fine the lot of them I say - in most shared student accommodation it seems the logic of "someone else will do it" prevails!”
by Tru Don, LE1
Thursday, September 03 2009, 2:50PM
“Here we go again! Yet another petty fine for yet another normal action (not an offence as it is made out to be).
Everybody pays their council tax so everybody should be allowed to put their bin where they want.
Using 'potential arson and cluttering' as an excuse is (excuse the pun) rubbish!
Have you seen some of the streets in Leicester? Forget rubbish bins they belong in a landfill site.
Just another way to bring in more money for the local authority.”
by Neil, Leicester
Thursday, September 03 2009, 2:40PM
“Bins cause less of a blockage to the footpath than illegally parked cars. Bins are also smaller than parked cars & easier to walk around.
Why not start by addressing the problem of cars parked on footpaths. They could fine the driver and all of the passengers.”
by Anita, Leicester
Thursday, September 03 2009, 2:24PM
“For Godfrey and the like. For those who are disabled and find it difficult to move the bins around. If you let the know they will collect your bin from where you keep it and return it back there afterwards.
For those able boddied folk who just can't be bothered to move their bin - pay the fine, get a life and move the bin in future!”
by Balan Singh, Fleckney
Thursday, September 03 2009, 2:15PM
“Jameel, there isn't an oxfam in Fleckney either.
Don't know what Bob's sexuality has got to do with the story either.”
by Carl, Leicester
Thursday, September 03 2009, 1:58PM
“In fairness to the bin men if they had to put every bin perfectly in its place they wouldn't get half as much done and i speak from experience having done the job as a temp. Having said that i do agree they shouldn't leave the bins just anywhere on the pavement or roadside.”
by bob down, leicester
Thursday, September 03 2009, 1:36PM
“Godfrey,
Your lying, there isn't a bookies in Fleckney.
I bet you've still got your original hips as well.”
by Sally, leicester
Thursday, September 03 2009, 1:16PM
“The hazards of these bins (particularly for visually-impaired people and others with disabilities) have been ignored for too long. The fines are working as they are sufficient to provide a deterrent. If they were divided amongst members of multiple occupancy households it would lose this effect. It is no harder on students - or unemployed graduates as in this case - than it is on single occupants on a low income. Provided alternative arrangements are made for those who are genuinely unable to move their bins, and is done after a warning, I think it is entirely fair.”
by Sam, Leicester
Thursday, September 03 2009, 1:03PM
“I agree with Jane, west end, the bin men shouldn't be so lazy and actually put the bins back outside houses where they found them instead of throwing them in the road, its awful! There the ones who aren't doing their job properly and should be fined!”