Parents battle to save Leicester primary school as decision day looms
Education bosses look set to go through with plans to close a school despite parents telling the council it was the wrong decision.
Leicestershire County Council's cabinet is due to make a decision tomorrow to formally move to close Holmfield Primary School, in Leicester Forest East.
-

It comes despite 80% of people responding to a consultation saying the school should stay open. People connected with nearby primary schools were concerned there would not be room for Holmfield children, if the closure went ahead.
But Councillor Ivan Ould, the county council cabinet's education spokesman, said the school's pupils deserved a better education – which Holmfield was failing to deliver.
He said: "Ofsted has serious, ongoing concerns about Holmfield.
"It placed the school into special measures last June and, by December, judged it was making inadequate progress.
"I met parents and told them that the return visit of Ofsted was a critically important factor in determining the outcome for the school.
"It was very disappointing that the judgement was inadequate, particularly since we have maintained our support for the school.
"I appreciate the majority of people who responded want to keep the school open – but Ofsted's concerns mean we have a legal duty to consider closing Holmfield and giving its pupils a better education at other schools nearby."
Officials first decided to consult on closure in October following an Ofsted report that put the school in special measures – a year after it had been first warned that standards were "inadequate".
Since the consultation began, more than 40 children have been removed from the school. If closure is approved, County Hall says there would be room in nearby schools.
However, about 40 of Holmfield's pupils come from Leicester and the county council said there would be fewer places available for children from the city.
One group of parents said they would be at the meeting at County Hall tomorrow. Many said they were concerned that their children would now have to go to schools which they considered not to be as good as Holmfield, or were further away.
Greg Hancock, of Braunstone, whose two sons are at the school, said: "We are disgusted more than anything else. They are saying we can find other schools.
"I have contacted three schools and they are all saying they are full and not taking any more pupils.''
Tracey Harris, of Braunstone, who has a daughter at the school, said: "They were always going to do this. They haven't listened to anyone but just carried on regardless.
"It is very disappointing, but we will be at the meeting still fighting for the school."
Tracey Keenan, of New Parks, had three children at the school but decided to move them to other schools because of its uncertain future.
She said: "It was a very big decision, but we felt we had to. But I am still disgusted. I feel so much for the other children that are left behind. It's devastating."
If the county cabinet agrees to publish a statutory notice, there will be a further six weeks' consultation before the cabinet takes a final decision in April.







7 Comments
by e, braunstone
Tuesday, February 09 2010, 11:33AM
“I moved my 2 children back in october and although we have a long walk twice a day i can see a big improvement in their education already. Their handwriting is 100%better for one. It is a great shame that the school is shutting i was a pupil there myself many years ago as was my mum. But if thats what it takes for our children to have the best start in life then so be it.”
by Hashrai, Belgrave
Monday, February 08 2010, 3:46PM
“Mindless! I really feel for the parents who may have to take their Children miles away to another School and not being able to settle. Watch the space for Housing.”
by Reuben B. Reynolds, Enderby, Leics.
Monday, February 08 2010, 12:31PM
“What sort of consultation can it be that can seemingly ignore an 80% response?”
by Nik, NW Leics
Monday, February 08 2010, 11:08AM
“If this school was struggling to improve despite being given time, and no doubt much support from the LA, then surely the obvious step before closure was to replace the existing Governing Body with high quality, experienced Governors and replace the Head Teacher.
I know that people will disagree with this comment but it is these people who lead the school and clearly they were not carrying out their roles sufficiently well enough to improve the teaching and learning at the school.
I know from experience that when a school is 'causing concern' to the LA, a whole raft of measures are put in place to help the school improve, and most schools will go on to flourish eventually. Assuming these mearues had been put into place and the school was still judged to be inadequate, then the children are being let down.
I strongly believe that a new Head and Governing Body, together with support and training for staff could turn the school around.
Parents ..... ask your Governors what they have been doing to monitor the schools performance over the years, and why they failed to spot that your children's education was suffering. That is their responsibility afterall.”
by Pete, Wigston, Leicestershire
Monday, February 08 2010, 10:53AM
“If councillors close all schools in special measures, just how many Leicester schools will be left?
But any councillor basing a decision on school closure on the results of an imprecise and poorly conducted Ofsted inspection is betraying a great lack of knowledge of the process of education. Perhaps they just want to sell off the land for housing.”
by Millimole, LFE
Monday, February 08 2010, 10:02AM
“Another example of how the current fashion for 'consultation' is a waste of time and taxpayers money.
(Yes it is a possessive - "the parents - their battle". So the apostrophe stays!)”
by Kulgan, Crydee
Monday, February 08 2010, 9:58AM
“When has a 'consultation' ever changed the pre-determined outcome?”