Stop meddling in the arts

Trusted article source icon
Tuesday, November 23, 2010
Profile image for This is Leicestershire

This is Leicestershire

What further desecration is Leicester City Council going to inflict on the arts in Leicester?

Is there one member of the council even modestly aware of the history, importance and influence Leicester musical, theatre, dance and visual arts have played in our city, not to mention in the arts of the UK?

Is there any awareness even of the name of Eric Pinkett, under whose guidance the arts from the 1950s through to the 1970s flourished within the school system of Leicestershire, so much so that school authorities throughout the UK were basing their music curriculum on his methods and achievements.

What of the Haymarket Theatre, an acoustically perfect, state-of-the-art theatre barely 35 years old and now sitting dark? Under Robin Midgley's inspired direction this theatre changed the face of regional theatre throughout the country.

As a result, following the Haymarket's nationally recognised productions of superbly-crafted musicals, London's West End reached out to regional theatre to mount productions prior to their London premieres.

No less a theatre producer of eminence than Cameron Macintosh built his reputation on shows which he mounted at the Haymarket Theatre prior to their West End runs. The first of several productions of Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat mounted at the Haymarket, the first large- scale productions following a less than successful run of Joseph in the London's West End, produced the seeds which bloomed to become the Joseph mania that has followed this remarkable stage work ever since.

Further desecration by the council to the arts of Leicester now involves its attempt to ban both the Leicester Symphony Orchestra and the Bardi Orchestra from using De Montfort Hall for their concert seasons.

Let it be clear that these orchestras are not given performing dates at the hall gratis; they both pay rental fees. The council is in search of increased revenue at the hall, which they believe they can achieve by renting to the latest craze rock groups whose high-priced ticket sales will produce larger commissions at the box office.

So the council's brief is simply that higher commissions are more important than community-based cultural activities of quality.

The most recent concert of the Leicester Symphony was a superbly mounted family concert conducted by a very talented young British conductor. The concert involved about 150 performers, about 60 of whom were students of dance, aged eight years through teen age, all trained by the doyenne of dance in Leicester, Ann Oliver.

This was a community happening at its best. As for its appeal, the audience was a balanced mixture of adults and young persons representing a wide age range. One of these young persons was the 14-year-old grandson of a dear friend who was attending with me. It was his very first concert. At the end of the evening, his enthusiasm bubbling over, he asked if he could attend the Bardi Orchestra concert taking place at the end of November. Is that single request not a wake-up call to the council to get their priorities in order.

The Curve Theatre is not an answer. It was built on a whim of megalomania. Its history so far is of a £62 million overspend, continued losses and mixed reviews, many unfavourable, unlike the original Haymarket which enjoyed during my six-year tenure unending praise from the local and national press and, most important of all, the people of Leicester.

Leicester City Council should stop meddling in the arts. Its history of doing so has been a disaster. Encouraging local arts of such distinguished accomplishment as can be accredited to the Leicester Symphony and the Bardi Orchestra should and must be its priority.

Robert Mandell, Leicester (executive music director, Haymarket Theatre 1973-79; music director, Concerts for the Family, 1968-2004; music director, The Melachrino Orchestra, 1975-2010).

4
Tweet this article
Report

4 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Leicestershire

    by John Percy, Australia

    Tuesday, January 18 2011, 1:43AM

    “Dear Robert.
    I applaud you for the comments you made concerning the Arts in Leicester. Many will remember the years that you gave so much to the development of music in Leicester. My daughter Sarah was a member of the choir and she too remembers how she was inspired by you and how much she enjoyed being able to share such wonderful experiences. Thank you "Bob
    ' John Percy”

  • Profile image for This is Leicestershire

    by The Watchman, Loughborough

    Tuesday, November 23 2010, 6:52PM

    “Adam

    By and large I agree with your comments and the sentiment. I also believe there is room for both rock and classical performances at de Monfort - I have attended many concerts by big name rock bands in the 70's & 80's, however it has dropped off the tour itinery radar and I doubt whether they would be sucessful in attracting the "latest craze" bands. But I do think there is a place for something like the Curve as a venue for more contempory arts. Its just that The Curve has become everyones favourite whipping boy when discussing the provision of live arts in Leicester; I have no easy answers as it remains a paradox when trying to equate venues being run as a commercial - in the context of not requiring subsidies not necessacrily for profit - versus what the arts represent and is trying to achieve in its many forms be it music, theatre, dance etc. If we just wanted to run venues on a commercial basis it would be the lowest commom denominator and we'd end up with a constant diet of Andrew Lloyd Webber.”

  • Profile image for This is Leicestershire

    by Jane Fooberry, suburbia

    Tuesday, November 23 2010, 2:35PM

    “I agree with the sentiments expressed in this letter, and will even allow 'desecrate' as a rhetorical device here.

    @Adam: 'complements'?”

  • Profile image for This is Leicestershire

    by Adam Clarke, Aylestone

    Tuesday, November 23 2010, 2:09PM

    “What a well written letter, with opinion derived from experience. Of course times need to change, but without learning from and valuing the past we cannot build a future with any meaning.
    This letter compliments my letter regarding De Montfort Hall of a couple of weeks ago: http://tinyurl.com/3x6gb6p”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters