A blow to Ivanhoe hopes

Trusted article source icon
Wednesday, December 03, 2008
Profile image for This is Leicestershire

This is Leicestershire

Reopening a historic railway route to passengers would cost tax-payers £50 million, it was revealed today.

Leicestershire County Council says it does not have enough cash to revive the Ivanhoe Line, which runs from Leicester to Burton-on-Trent.

The route, now the National Forest Line, has been studied by experts for the past six months.

Their job has been to identify the infrastructure needed, where trains would stop and how much cash it would take to run the line.

County Hall, which released the report today, says new stations would be built at Bede Island, in Leicester, Leicester Forest East, Kirby Muxloe, Coalville, Ashby, Moira and Castle Gresley, in South Derbyshire, if the project went ahead.

After the infrastructure was built, at a cost of £50 million, about £5 million a year would be then be needed to run it.

Researchers believe around 150,000 people a year would use the line, raising more than £500,000 if each paid an average single fare of £3.15.

But to make it financially viable, passenger numbers would need to be 10 times that amount, they say.

Council bosses say the Government would have to step in with cash, otherwise the project cannot get off the ground.

Cabinet member for transport, Councillor Nicholas Rushton, said: "It is a massive amount of money, and it is way beyond the means of this council.

"Everyone knows how great this would be for Leicestershire, but we could not achieve this on our own.

"I will be writing to ask the transport minister to consider funding the set-up costs."

Regular train services between Leicester and Burton, via Coalville and Ashby, have long been seen as a way to slash traffic congestion in the area.

County Hall believes the line could regenerate parts of north west Leicestershire and help cope with housing growth.

Freight traffic runs on the Ivanhoe Line, but it has not carried passengers since the 1960s.

Campaigner Gerald Box, of Appleby Magna, said: "I do not see that this should be abandoned.

"There is still a steady trickle of use from freight transport. Coal, aggregate and clay companies could be spoken to and convinced to pay towards the running of the line. They should have a rail expert employed full time on this project. They did this for canal restoration, and it has been a success."

County councillors voted to shelve the passenger scheme in 2000 after being told rail privatisation had made it too costly.

It was revealed, even if County Hall received more than £13 million to launch the service, an annual subsidy of £2.2million would have to be found towards running costs.

This figure is vastly below what it is believed is needed now.

County council transport expert Ian Drummond said: "There will be people who will be disappointed about what has been found in this report. It is looking almost impossible for us to do it on our own."

14
Tweet this article
Report

14 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Leicestershire

    by Helen Fairhead, Leicester

    Wednesday, December 03 2008, 2:15PM

    “I believe this would be excellent for the City and County. I live at LFE and work at Bede Island and considering there are no direct buses (nearest one is St Nicholas Circle it would be ideal. Think £6.30 per day would be a bit steep though! If the government are desperate to get people off the roads, then they should invest in these alternative schemes. Perhaps County Hall are worried that if the congestion comes down too much, they won't be able to charge as many people (travelling to work) a congestion charge!”

  • Profile image for This is Leicestershire

    by BWB, MH

    Wednesday, December 03 2008, 2:13PM

    “to LFE it's 'bored with you'!”

  • Profile image for This is Leicestershire

    by DAVE, LEICESTER

    Wednesday, December 03 2008, 2:08PM

    “The council keep going on about how our roads are gridlocked, yet heres a chance to put into place an infrastructure that will serve for many years , Yet they seem quite happy to let it get worse resulting in them being able to implement a congestion charge to further line our councillors rapily rising expenses.”

  • Profile image for This is Leicestershire

    by Mr LFE, LFE

    Wednesday, December 03 2008, 1:30PM

    “What a shame we can't use the money which is being used/put by for something which seems to be a waste.
    We can all see what's best - why can't the council...after all, it is our money...isn't it?


    Again, someone is bleating on about the soon-to-be eco-town on another news subject.

    GIVE IT A REST!

    Moan about it when the soon-to-be eco-town is in the news - don't hijack other news stories to get your moans and groans in all the live-long day...we're bored of you!”

  • Profile image for This is Leicestershire

    by Jim Taylor, Loughborough

    Wednesday, December 03 2008, 1:28PM

    “One cannot help feeling a sense of despair reading the comments so far, particularly from one correspondent who seems to believe that reopening a rail line to passenger traffic simply involves putting a few concrete blocks down.

    When will people in this country realise that there is not an unlimited pot of money, and that all these things have to be paid for by the taxpayer? Based on the figures provided reopening this line to passengers would have only a small effect on traffic congestion - for example it would be useless for anyone travelling to County Hall, Glenfield Hospital etc. I for one as a Council Tax payer, am very pleased that the County Council has displayed a very responsible attitude to to this project. The Labour Party policy as typified by Eric Goodyer of throwing money at things without proper thought has surely been long discredited.
    Which part of the Council's figures does he disagree with?”

        Your comments awaiting moderation

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article