The well-heeled at war

Trusted article source icon
Thursday, February 02, 2012
Profile image for Leicester Mercury

Leicester Mercury

Director Roman Polanski strips away the veneer of civility that supposedly separates man from beasts and reduces two well-to-do couples to snarling adversaries in this film version of the award-winning stage comedy God Of Carnage.

Playwright Yasmina Reza adapts her celebrated work for the big screen, entrusting her incendiary dialogue to a stellar cast including three former Oscar winners, who deliver each verbal grenade with lip-smacking relish.

It's an acting tour de force, the tension heightened by the claustrophobic setting of a swish Brooklyn apartment overlooking the park, where an act of aggression between two children provides the dramatic spark for the hostility.

Polanski works closely with cinematographer Pawel Edelman to move the argument around the claustrophobic space.

Yet the piece's origins are unmistakable and Reza's comical coup de theatre – a character projectile vomiting across the stage when a piece of homemade cobbler unsettles her stomach – doesn't have quite the same impact when it's behind the cinematic fourth wall.

Alan Cowan (Christoph Waltz) and his wife Nancy (Kate Winslet) visit the apartment of Michael and Penelope Longstreet (John C Reilly, Jodie Foster) to apologise for their son Zachary, who has hit the Longstreets' son Ethan in the face with a stick.

The meeting is intended to be brief and courteous and Alan tries to speed along proceedings by candidly and brusquely admitting "Our son is a maniac.

"If you hope he'll suddenly and spontaneously get all apologetic, you're dreaming."

As the conversation ebbs and flows, tensions become evident until poor Nancy is taken ill and spoils Penelope's prized Kokoschka art catalogue.

The Cowans head for the bathroom to clean up while the Longstreets seethe.

"Their son is a threat to homeland security!" shrieks Penelope, barely able to contain her middle-class fury.

Once the guests return to the sitting room, verbal exchanges become increasingly terse and heated until all sense of decorum disintegrates and the couples lash out just like their boys.

Carnage lives up to its title, decimating the characters' facades of politeness and charm as collective tempers fray.

Waltz is thoroughly obnoxious as the corporate lawyer, while Winslet degenerates from simpering peacemaker to cackling harpy.

Foster and Reilly are equally strong, turning on each other about the sensitive issue of their nine-year-old daughter's pet hamster.

Polanski allows the machine-gun dialogue to dictate the rhythm of the film.

The camerawork and editing become increasingly frenetic as everyone competes for the delicious last word.

0
Tweet this article
Report

Your comments awaiting moderation

Be the first to comment

max 4000 characters